OK, I will admit this seems like an odd category to have.  But lets admit that we don't all have time to play a game right when it comes out.  As such there was a majority vote to at least list the games that some of the staff did not get a chance to play until they were no longer eligible for the awards.  These games are:

Rune Factory 3
Defense Grid
Mass Effect II
Fable II

No real award is being given hear, since none of these are eligible (as previously mentioned). But if you have not had a chance, give one of these a go.